Project History
Petroleum Industry Operations History:
The northeast area of Greenpoint, between North Henry Street, Norman Avenue, and
Newtown Creek, has been heavily industrialized and the site of various petroleum
industries for over 140 years. Oil refining operations date back to 1834 with the
refining of whale oil. According to one published report, petroleum refining operations
began as early as 1854, with the production of kerosene, as naptha and gasoline
were considered by-products of the refining process. By 1870 over 50 refineries
were located along the banks of Newtown Creek and by 1892, the majority of the area
refineries were purchased and consolidated into the Standard Oil Trust. Around 1900,
gasoline and fuel oils became the dominant product refined or stored in terminal
facilities in the Greenpoint area. Following the breakup of the Trust in 1911, ownership
of the refinery property in Greenpoint reverted to the Standard Oil Company of New
York (SOCONY) and these operations became the SOCONY (later Mobil Oil Corporation)
Brooklyn Refinery. The refinery reportedly had a capacity to refine over 33,000
barrels (1.4 million gallons) of crude oil a day and produced fuel oils, gasoline,
kerosene, and refinery oil. Also stored within the former refinery were petroleum
additives and miscellaneous refining by-products.
Refinery operations at the former ExxonMobil Brooklyn Refinery ceased in 1966. The
refinery was subsequently demolished and significant portions of the refinery property
were sold. Several of the subdivided lots were retained by Mobil Oil Corporation,
while the other lots were sold to Amoco Oil Company (now known as BP), United Kingsway
Carpet Company (subsequently renamed Long Island Carpet Cleaners, Inc.), and others.
The lots retained by ExxonMobil were utilized as a petroleum bulk storage terminal
until 1993, when storage operations ceased at the property.
Amoco Oil Company (currently BP) purchased a parcel of the former ExxonMobil Brooklyn
Refinary in 1968 and constructed a bulk fuel storage terminal on its portion of
the property that began operation in 1970 and which continues in operation today.
The BP terminal is 9.98 acres and has 12 aboveground and 1 underground storage tanks,
with 2 loading racks. The storage capacity of the terminal is 5,902,512 gallons
and has been used to store diesel fuel, #2 fuel oil, kerosene, gasoline, and ethanol.
In addition to the petroleum facilities on the former ExxonMobil terminal site,
the Paragon Oil Company occupied a portion of the property north of Bridgewater
Street, between Apollo Street and Meeker Avenue. Paragon Oil was purchased in 1960
by Texaco Oil, now known as Chevron-Texaco Corporation. Paragon operated a terminal
storing gasoline, kerosene, diesel fuel, fuel oil (numbers 2, 4, and 6) and lube
oil at this location until approximately 1968 when Peerless Importers (now Empire
Merchants) purchased the property and constructed a warehouse for its operations.
Remediation/Recovery History:
On September 2, 1978, the U. S. Coast Guard was making a routine helicopter patrol
of Newtown Creek when it noticed the signs of an oil spill entering Newtown Creek
from the area at the end of Meeker Avenue. A subsequent investigation concluded
that the area of the spill under the Greenpoint area was in excess of 52 acres and
the total spill volume, as estimated in 1979, was approximately 17 million gallons
of petroleum products.
The product beneath the Greenpoint spill area consist of a blend of petroleum related
liquids (oils, naphtha, kerosene, gasoline, etc). This blend rests at the top of
the water table as a free product plume, which currently is known to extend as far
north as the ExxonMobil Brooklyn terminal, as far south as the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway,
and to the west to an area located between Monitor Street and Kingsland Avenue.
The plume has impacted the soils and groundwater in both a shallow aquifer under
the former refinery properties and a deeper regional aquifer that extends outside
the former refinery areas.
Petroleum product recovery operations are currently being conducted within five
distinct areas: the former ExxonMobil Terminal, the BP Terminal, the commercial/industrial/residential
area southwest of the BP Terminal known as the ExxonMobil Off-Site Plume, the site
of the former Paragon Oil Terminal, which is currently the location of the Peerless
Importers/Empire Merchants distribution facility, and the Apollo Street Creek Parcels
located between the BP Terminal and the site of the former Paragon Oil Terminal.
Product recovery systems have been in place since 1979. ExxonMobil entered into
two consent orders with NYSDEC in 1990 and began upgrades to its recovery systems,
including the design and construction of a new and expanded system to recover free
product from the Off-Site Area. Following the discovery of free product seepage
through the facility's bulkhead into Newtown Creek, ExxonMobil also began recovery
activities at the Peerless Importers/former Paragon Oil site in February 1991. Mobil
continued recovery activities until May 2005 when Texaco took over that portion
of the project.
This
depiction is one representation of plume extent. Due to product recovery and continuing
investigation, knowledge and conditions are changing. Involved parties have slight
variations on this general depiction based on 2008 information.
Remediation Methods:
The primary technology used to recover free product from the major portions of the
plume is a dual-pump free-product recovery system. In a dual-pump recovery system,
recovery wells are installed with both a product pump and a groundwater pump within
the same well. When activated, the groundwater pump extracts water from the aquifer
beneath the product, which lowers the water table and causes a cone of depression
to form in the vicinity of the recovery well. This cone of depression then induces
free product floating on top of the ground water to flow into the depression and
towards the recovery well, where it is periodically removed by the product pump
based on the amount of free product in the well. In addition, collected groundwater
is treated, and discharged.
Free
product recovered from each well is conveyed to storage tanks located adjacent to
each recovery well, while the extracted groundwater is conveyed through underground
pipes to a centralized water treatment system. At the water treatment system, the
groundwater is treated through a variety of processes to remove contaminants. These
processes can include oil-water separation, aeration and filtration to remove certain
metals (such as iron and magnesium) and air stripping to remove volatile organic
compound (VOC) and semi-volatile organic compound (SVOC) contaminants found in the
groundwater. The treated groundwater is then discharged to Newtown Creek under NYSDEC
permits. The treated groundwater is monitored on a monthly basis to ensure compliance
with the discharge limits specified by NYSDEC. Air emissions from the treatment
process are controlled through either a catalytic oxidation unit or a carbon adsorption
unit.
Four different free product recovery systems are currently operating in Greenpoint.
These include the former ExxonMobil Terminal Recovery and Containment System (RCS),
the BP Terminal Recovery System, the ExxonMobil Off-Site Plume Recovery System and
the former Paragon Oil Terminal Recovery System. Significant treatment system upgrades
to increase the free product recovery capacity and water treatment capabilities
of all the recovery systems have been completed over the years. The ExxonMobil Terminal
RCS currently includes 5 active dual-pump free-product recovery wells and a water
treatment system with a capacity of up to 450 gallons per minute (gpm) that treats
water from both the ExxonMobil and BP terminal systems. The BP Terminal system includes
8 dual-pump free product recovery wells. The ExxonMobil Off-Site Plume Recovery
System, which was completed in 1995 as part of the Consent Order with DEC, includes
15 active dual-pump free-product recovery wells and a central water treatment system
with a capacity of up to 430 gpm. An expansion of the system completed in 2009 added
10 of these recovery wells. The former Paragon Oil Terminal recovery system currently
consists of 12 total fluids recovery pumps that remove both product and water for
subsequent separation and treatment.
Through these combined efforts, a total of over 11.4 million gallons of product has been recovered, and over 3.8 billion gallons of groundwater has been recovered and treated. Recent groundwater pumping rates (late 2009) have exceeded 1,000,000 gallons of groundwater per day that is treated and discharged in one of the active systems. Since 1979, the ExxonMobil and BP terminal systems have recovered over
1.5 million gallons and 3.0 million gallons of free product, respectively. The Meeker
Avenue Task Force, operated by Mobil and Amoco from 1979 to 1989 at the foot of
Meeker Avenue in the Off-Site Area, recovered an additional 800,000 gallons of free
product. The ExxonMobil Off-Site Free-Product Recovery System, which replaced the
Meeker Avenue Task Force system, has recovered over 5.2 million gallons of free
product to date. In 2010, a total of approximately 740,000 gallons of petroleum products was recovered by the project.
Investigation of Soil Vapor and Residential Indoor Air:
On September 16, 2005, NYSDEC approved a work plan from ExxonMobil to sample soil
gas at approximately 16 additional points in the Greenpoint Area around the off-site
product plume. The goal of the sampling was to determine if vapors from the product
plume are attenuated before impacting indoor air as believed based on earlier investigations.
ExxonMobil started the investigation on September 19, 2005 and it was later completed
by NYSDEC and NYSDOH. A report on the State's sampling was finalized in March 2006
and is available on the Public Documents page
of this website.
The soil vapor investigation conducted by Exxon-Mobil in 2005 concluded that the
free-product plume is not contributing to concentration of contaminants in residential
indoor air. The depth of the contamination allowing for its biodegradation and presence
of a clay/silt layer to prevent migration are factors in its conclusion. The Department
has reviewed the data and agrees with the report’s conclusion; however, in order
to confirm (or refute) this hypothesis, the Department conducted a residential indoor
air investigation to collect the data necessary to verify this conceptual model.
During the 2006-07 winter heating season, a vapor intrusion sampling investigation
was completed at 52 properties in the Greenpoint area of Brooklyn by the NYSDEC.
The study area was selected by NYSDEC and consisted primarily of residential structures
with some commercial operations. Sampling was conducted at structures for which
property owners and tenants had volunteered and provided permission. Sampling consisted
of concurrently collecting vapor/air samples from beneath the building slab, ambient
basement air, ambient air from the first floor (if the basement was not used as
living space), and ambient outdoor air. As stated above, a report of results is
available on the Public Documents page of this
website. As a result of this effort, the State believes it is unlikely that vapor
intrusion from the subsurface plume is occurring in the buildings tested.
During the winter of 2007-08, the State also conducted follow-up sampling at approximately
20% of the homes included in the initial sampling. These results were consistent
with the initial sampling and have confirmed conclusions draw to date. In September
2009, NYSDOH and ATSDR concluded that petroleum-related compounds in the ExxonMobil
Greenpoint Off-site free-product plume area are not expected to harm people's health
via the soil vapor intrusion pathway.
An assessment of soil vapor in the commercial/industrial area above the contamination
has continued. Elevated levels of methane, benzene, and other petroleum related
compounds are known to exist in commercial and industrial areas around past petroleum
storage and distribution operations. Notifications regarding these results have
been sent to businesses in areas with potential impacts. In addition, the Department
has required ExxonMobil to conduct indoor air sampling within some locations in
this area to assess any potential impact. Finally, an interim soil vapor extraction system was in operation for a portion of the commercial zone from September 2009 until June 2010 when a permanent Mitigation System was brought online.